Welcome to Garbonzo's Pizza
At Garbonzo's Pizza, we embrace a passion for crafting exceptional pizzas in New Plymouth, Idaho. Our story begins with the desire to provide not only mouthwatering cheese pizzas but also an opportunity for guests to create their own unique flavors. Our menu extends beyond pizza, featuring delectable sandwiches like the Santa Fe Chicken and the Great Garbonzo, each made with fresh ingredients. Customers rave about our generous toppings and inviting atmosphere, making us a beloved spot in the community. With a commitment to quality and customer service, we are proud to be the best-kept secret in New Plymouth, satisfying cravings one slice at a time.
Garbonzo's Pizza: Reviews & Ratings
I want to highlight your employee Dylan! She has absolutely amazing customer service every time!!!
This place (New Plymouth) has amazing food!!!! You will not be disappointed by the food here!!!! Update Tried the Santa Fe tonight OMG sooo good!!
Tried this place for the first time today and was really pleased! The pizza is exceptional and the don't skimp on the toppings. The salad bar looked small, but was actually pretty impressive for it's size. Staff were helpful and friendly.
Clean establishment. Bathrooms are kept clean. Background music isn't too loud. Reasonable prices. Basic salad bar with one time serving or all you can eat option.
NEW PLYMOUTH BEST KEPT SECRET I had a medium pizza custom made it started as the delectable ranch chicken. All I did was add sausages and extra cheese. Not only was the pizza heavy in the box, but the pizzas waz 10 times better than idaho pizza. I should know I'm the pizza guy. it smells great tasted great ask for Joshua ammaza pizza maker.
Are you ready for an unforgettable taste bud extravaganza?! Then get ready and buckle up for a once in a lifetime pizza party. Take everything you thought you know about pizza and throw it out there widow, while your senses are tantalized by these mouth watering flavors! A sauce that will put all other sauces to shame. Cheese that will leave you pleased. Fixing problems, one slice at a time! Garbonzo's pizza is the 8th wonder of the world and the best kept secret in the United States.
Great local pizza. House made meatballs and pizza sauce with fresh grated mozzarella is top-notch! Our favorite pizza with delicious crust! Outstanding service, and they had no problem honoring our custom order.
The young curly haired' redhead is great! Nice, funny & extremely professional!! The Calzones are HUGE & beyond delicious. Three full sized dinners for 36 bucks! Super dank!
Location
-
116 N Plymouth Ave, New Plymouth, ID 83655, United States Hotline: +1 208-278-5300
Welcome to Garbonzo's Pizza, a hidden gem nestled in the heart of New Plymouth, Idaho. Located at 116 N Plymouth Ave, this inviting pizzeria has quickly become a local favorite, known for its mouthwatering pizzas and warm, inviting atmosphere. Whether you are craving classic flavors or adventurous toppings, Garbonzo's has something for everyone.
One of the standout selections at Garbonzo's is their Hawaiian Pizza, a delightful mix of ham and pineapple that strikes the perfect balance of sweet and savory. If you’re in the mood for something a bit more robust, try the Santa Fe Pizza, featuring grilled chicken, BBQ sauce, and a medley of cheeses that dance on your palate. Moreover, their Cheesesteak Pizza offers a unique twist with sautéed beef and hearty toppings, while the Everything Pizza is a feast for those who can’t choose just one topping.
Don’t overlook Garbonzo's sandwiches either. The Santa Fe Chicken Sandwich combines BBQ sauce with cheddar and mild green chilies for a flavor explosion. And if you are seeking comfort food, the Meatball Sandwich smothered in pizza sauce and gooey mozzarella delivers just that. Each dish is prepared with fresh ingredients, showcasing the pizzaiolo's dedication to quality.
But it's not just about the food at Garbonzo's. Customers rave about the exceptional service. As Ashley Travis noted, employee Dylan consistently offers amazing customer service, making every visit memorable. Patrons like Jason Gillis have praised the deliciousness of the meals, with the Santa Fe pizza earning a special mention for its incredible taste. It’s this attention to service and quality that has cemented Garbonzo's as a beloved establishment in the community.
For those who appreciate variety, the small salad bar may surprise you with its impressive selection, allowing for the perfect side to your pizza. Eric Blackmun emphasized the clean ambiance and reasonable prices, making Garbonzo's a spot where you can relax and enjoy your meal. Not to mention, the establishment has been hailed as New Plymouth's best-kept secret by Ray Nunez, who speaks to the generous portions and tantalizing aroma of their custom-made pizzas.
In summary, Garbonzo's Pizza is not just a place to eat; it's an experience. With a diverse menu, friendly service, and an ambiance that invites you to sit back and savor each bite, it's easy to see why this pizzeria has become a favorite among locals. So why not come and discover the magic of Garbonzo's Pizza for yourself? Your taste buds will thank you!